Are you watching the real estate market and feeling a bit confused? You're not alone. While the idea of home prices consistently going up might be what many of us are used to, the truth is, home prices are dropping in more than half of the major cities across the country right now. This isn't just a small blip; it's a noticeable shift with several important factors at play.
From my own experience watching this market, it's clear that the days of double-digit price increases year after year are taking a pause. The market is currently undergoing a rebalancing act, and understanding why this is happening is crucial for anyone thinking about buying or selling a home.
Why Are Home Prices Dropping in Over Half of Major US Cities in 2025?
The Big Picture: A Slowdown Across the Board
Let's look at the numbers. While national home values are still showing a slight increase year-over-year – around 1.3% according to the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller Index in September – this is the slowest annual gain since mid-2023. What's more, this national average is being pulled up by a few strong markets. Dig a little deeper, and you'll find that in 11 out of the 20 major metropolitan areas tracked by this index, home values have actually fallen on an annual basis.
You might be wondering which cities are seeing these declines. The data points to areas in the South and West, with places like Tampa, Florida, experiencing the biggest year-over-year drops. Even with these drops, it's important to remember that homes in these very same cities are still significantly more valuable than they were just a few years ago. For instance, Tampa homes are still about 55% higher than they were five years back.
On the flip side, some cities are still seeing growth. Chicago, for example, reported the biggest annual gain. This shows how uneven the market is right now; it's not a one-size-fits-all situation.
What's Driving These Price Drops? Let's Break It Down.
So, what’s causing this shift? It’s a combination of factors, but the two biggest players are high mortgage rates and tough affordability challenges.
- Mortgage Rates That Just Won't Quit: Remember when mortgage rates were in the 2-3% range? Those days feel like a distant memory. While rates have dipped slightly from their highest points (below 6.3% from Freddie Mac recently), they've remained stubbornly high for most of the past year, averaging around 6.35% in September. For potential buyers, this means their monthly payments are much higher, even if the sticker price of the house hasn't changed. This directly impacts how much house they can afford.
- Affordability is a Major Hurdle: When you combine high home prices that were driven up by years of low interest rates with current higher mortgage rates, you get a perfect storm for affordability issues. As Nick Godec, who tracks these markets, put it, the market is settling into an “equilibrium of minimal price growth—or, in some regions, outright decline.” It’s simply too expensive for many people to buy a home right now.
- Demand Takes a Hit: When buying a home becomes a stretch financially, demand naturally cools off. Buyers are either forced to wait, hoping rates or prices will drop further, or they are looking for smaller homes, less desirable locations, or just giving up on homeownership for now. Anthony Smith from Realtor.com® notes that while there's been some buyer activity, “sticky home prices and high borrowing costs continue to strain affordability, keeping home sales at historically low levels.”
- Inflation Plays a Role Too: When you look at home price growth compared to inflation, you see another layer to the story. For the past four months, national home prices have grown slower than the overall inflation rate (Consumer Price Index). This means that, in real, inflation-adjusted terms, home prices are actually slightly decreasing. This gives a small glimmer of hope for affordability, but it doesn't erase the fact that prices are still high.
A Look at the Numbers: September Data Snapshot
To really see what's going on, let's consider some key figures from September:
| Metro Area | Year-over-Year Home Price Change | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Tampa, FL | -4.14% | Seeing the largest decline |
| Phoenix | -2.02% | Another major city with falling prices |
| Chicago | +5.45% | Led the nation in price appreciation |
| New York City | +5.25% | Followed closely behind Chicago |
| National Avg. | +1.3% | Slowest annual gain since mid-2023 |
Source: S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller Index (September data)
It's interesting to see how some previously hot markets are now cooling down. This is a strong indicator that the national trends are real and affecting diverse locations.
My Take: It's About Finding a New Normal
From what I've seen, this isn't necessarily a crash in the making. Instead, it feels more like the market is correcting itself after a period of incredibly rapid growth fueled by historically low interest rates. Many of us in the real estate world felt that the pace of appreciation was unsustainable.
The current situation is forcing buyers and sellers to be more realistic. Buyers are being more selective, and sellers who are eager to sell might need to adjust their expectations on price. It’s a return to a more balanced market where demand and supply, along with economic conditions, are the primary drivers, rather than just the fear of missing out.
What Does This Mean for You?
If you're thinking about buying:
- You might have more negotiating power. With prices softening in some areas and fewer bidding wars, you might be able to get a better deal.
- Affordability is still key. Make sure you're comfortable with your monthly payments, even with slightly lower prices or rates.
- Do your homework. Research your local market because trends can vary greatly from city to city.
If you're thinking about selling:
- Price your home realistically. Overpricing will likely lead to your home sitting on the market longer.
- Consider making improvements. A well-maintained and appealing home will stand out.
- Be patient. Selling might take a bit longer than it did a year or two ago.
The housing market is constantly evolving. While home prices are dropping in many major cities, it's a complex picture. Understanding the forces at play – high mortgage rates, affordability crunch, and a return to more realistic valuations – will help you navigate these changes with confidence.
Home Prices Are Falling Across Major U.S. Cities
In 2025, more than half of major U.S. housing markets are seeing price declines—driven by affordability pressures, higher inventory, and shifting buyer demand.
For turnkey investors, this correction is opening doors to discounted properties with strong rental demand—Norada Real Estate helps you identify the best deals before prices stabilize.
🔥 HOT NEW Investor Deals JUST ADDED! 🔥
Talk to a Norada investment counselor today (No Obligation):
(800) 611-3060
Want to Know More About the Housing Market Trends?
Explore these related articles for even more insights:
- Redfin's Bold Predictions About The Great Housing Market Reset in 2026
- 5 Most Expensive Housing Markets Are Now Seeing the Biggest Price Cuts
- Housing Market Predicted to See Strong Growth in 2026: Expert Forecast
- Housing Market Predictions for the Next 12 Months by Zillow
- Housing Market Regains Ground as Falling Mortgage Rates Unlock Buyer Savings
- Hidden Costs of Homeownership Now Add Up to Nearly $16,000 a Year
- Small Investors Dominate the Housing Market From Detroit to Vegas
- Housing Market Predictions for the Next 4 Years: 2025 to 2029
- Housing Market 2025 Splits Between Wealthy Buyers and First-Timers
- Housing Markets at Risk of Double-Digit Price Decline Over the Next 12 Months
- Will the Housing Market Shift to a Buyer’s Market in 2026?
- Mid-Atlantic Housing Market Heats Up as Mortgage Rates Go Down












