Unpacking the CoreLogic S&P Case-Shiller Index: Is the US Housing Market Shifting Gears? The latest data from this leading home price index can shed light on whether the scorching US housing market is finally seeing a change in pace. Let's explore the key trends the index reveals, explore how these trends vary across different regions, and ultimately translate this information into actionable insights for both home buyers and sellers navigating today's dynamic market landscape.
Housing Market Cooling Faster Than Expected
Recent data from the US CoreLogic S&P Case-Shiller Index reveals a flattening of annual growth at 6.5% in March, accompanied by a notable surge in seasonal price gains.
Despite the prevailing high mortgage rates, home prices continue to escalate, with monthly appreciation in March reaching 1.3%. However, the housing market, overall, seems to be operating at a slower pace, reminiscent of second gear. While there is a gradual increase in inventory, home sales are only marginally surpassing last year's figures in most markets.
This marginal improvement in inventory availability is a positive sign, indicating a gradual thawing and normalization of housing markets across the country. However, regional disparities persist, both in terms of inventory levels and demand dynamics.
Regional Variations
In markets such as Florida, Texas, and the Southeast, where inventory improvements are most pronounced, there has been a cooling of demand compared to the frenzy witnessed last year.
This has resulted in a rapid deceleration of home price growth. The latest CoreLogic HPI data identifies the top five markets experiencing this cooling effect: New Orleans, Austin, San Antonio, Cape Coral, and North Port. These areas are characterized by either significant supply gains or concerns over rising homeownership expenses, including insurance and maintenance costs.
Furthermore, regions prone to weather-related disasters face additional challenges, as rising insurance costs and availability concerns could potentially lead to home price declines in the future.
Conversely, markets in the Northeast and West continue to grapple with inventory shortages, driving strong demand and consequent appreciation. Despite facing sales challenges, particularly in the San Francisco Bay Area, these markets exhibit robust home price gains, contributing to the overall national index.
Housing Market Trends: Analysis of March Data
In March, the U.S. CoreLogic S&P Case-Shiller Index revealed intriguing insights into the housing market, marking the ninth consecutive month of annual appreciation at a rate of 6.5%. This steady growth trend since early 2023 has propelled home prices to a remarkable 2.7% increase compared to the peak observed in June 2022.
Of particular interest is the non-seasonally adjusted month-over-month index, which exhibited a robust seasonal surge of 1.3% in March. This surge surpasses the average monthly increase of 0.8% recorded between 2015 and 2019, highlighting the current strength of the market compared to historical norms.
The 10-city and 20-city composite indexes also reflected this trend, both posting their ninth consecutive month of annual increases in March. The 10-city index, encompassing metro areas such as New York and Chicago, exhibited accelerated growth at 8.2%, indicative of the resurgence in urban housing markets as people return to cities and offices.
Conversely, the 20-city index showcased a more varied landscape, with pandemic-era boomtowns experiencing a resetting of excessive home price gains. Markets like Tampa, Florida, and Detroit, which had seen significant appreciation over the past year, are now witnessing some cooling.
Comparing current indices with the peak observed in 2006, the 10-city composite index has soared by 51%, while the 20-city composite has risen by an impressive 57%. When adjusted for inflation, the 10-city index stands 3% higher than its 2006 level, with the 20-city index up by 7%.
Nationally, home prices have surged by 16% when adjusted for inflation, reflecting the overall growth and resilience of the housing market compared to pre-recession levels.
Insights into Metropolitan Areas
March brought forth a nuanced picture of the housing market, with varying degrees of price growth across different metropolitan areas. While the acceleration in annual gains continues to reflect comparisons with the home price trough in early 2023, the divergence in rates of appreciation compared to the previous month highlights the tale of two markets.
In March, only half of the twenty metros observed faster price growth year over year compared to the previous month. This discrepancy underscores the challenges faced by some markets contending with rising non-mortgage costs and subdued demand, resulting in slower rates of home price growth.
Leading the 20-city index were San Diego, New York, Cleveland, and Los Angeles, boasting annual gains ranging from 8.8% to 11.1%. Notably, twelve metros outpaced the national 6.5% increase, with San Diego marking its third consecutive month of double-digit annual increases.
Among the metros, Cleveland, Seattle, and Boston exhibited the strongest annual price acceleration compared to the previous month. Conversely, Portland, Oregon, and Denver emerged as the slowest appreciating markets, recording modest gains of slightly more than 2% compared to the previous year.
On a monthly basis, while home prices increased nationally by 1.3% from February to March, seventeen metros recorded even stronger monthly gains. Seattle, San Francisco, and Cleveland led the pack with gains ranging from 2.4% to 2.7%. However, Tampa stood out as the only market experiencing a monthly loss, with prices dipping by 0.2% in March.
Interestingly, Tampa witnessed a notable increase in new listings during the spring, potentially contributing to the cooling of prices in the market. Similarly, markets in the Southeast and Southwest, including Miami, Charlotte, Las Vegas, and Phoenix, saw relatively weaker appreciation compared to their counterparts in the West and Midwest.
Insights into Price Tiers and Locations
In March, most metros and price tiers continued to witness home price appreciation, indicating ongoing market resilience. However, Tampa stood out once again as the only market experiencing price declines, particularly in the low-tier segment.
High-tier home prices led the pace of appreciation, increasing by an average of 1.8%, followed by the middle tier at 1.5%, and the low tier at 1.4%. Notably, San Francisco's middle and high tiers appreciated by more than 3%, showcasing the robustness of certain markets amidst broader trends.
While the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller Index reflects the overall resiliency of home prices amid surging borrowing costs, it also underscores persistent challenges facing the housing market.
Affordability issues loom large for potential homebuyers, exacerbated by skyrocketing non-mortgage costs such as homeowners' insurance and property tax increases. These escalating costs are compelling some sellers and investors to offload properties, raising concerns about the long-term implications for homeowners, particularly those with fixed incomes.
The weakness observed in low-tier home prices in Tampa underscores the potential challenges posed by affordability constraints. This trend highlights the importance of addressing the impact of non-mortgage costs on both potential homebuyers and existing homeowners.
On a positive note, markets in proximity to major employment centers and those that may have lagged in price strength during the pandemic are now driving much of the increase in home prices.
Strong labor markets in recent years, coupled with wage and wealth gains, are fueling demand in these areas. However, a scarcity of homes for sale and limited new construction are exerting upward pressure on prices, posing challenges for buyers seeking affordability.
In conclusion, while certain markets exhibit robust price appreciation driven by strong demand and economic factors, addressing affordability constraints remains a pressing issue that necessitates collective action from stakeholders across the housing spectrum.
ALSO READ:
Housing Market Predictions for the Next 2 Years
Housing Market Predictions for Next 5 Years (2024-2028)
Housing Market Predictions: 5 Metros to Become More Affordable
Housing Market Predictions 2024: Will Real Estate Crash?
Housing Market Predictions: 8 of Next 10 Years Poised for Gains
Prediction: Interest Rates Falling Below 6% Will Explode the Housing Market
